ShaeGuy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[What If Adult Link REALLY Did Young Link Dungeons?]

I can't speak for everyone here, but this was hitting nostalgia territory for me lol. This was such a delight. And I'm a real sucker for animations that cross 2D and 3D together. Also yeah those 3D backgrounds were pretty cute and creative. My only nitpick is that sometimes a scene can drag for too long when it probably could've been cut. While some people may find that boring, I found it wholesome. The point is that I loved this submission. Keep up the great work! :)

NahManacles responds:

Wow, thank you! And yeah, you're probably right about some scenes being too long, I haven't really made a big animation like this before so I'm still figuring out pacing and stuff.

[Comedy Animation]

Ok that was actually kinda funny lol. It's nothing amazing, but it did put a smile on my face. Just keep on practicing and making your small projects. One day you could be making some big hilarious stuff. Good luck! :)

Danimations7 responds:

Thank you! I know, It's just a few hours of work :)

[GENIE OF THE CAN]

My only "criticism" is that there wasn't much animation in this, but obviously it was a school project so I can't be too hard on it. Though my legit nitpick is maybe have some background music going on. Having music alone can engage your audience some. But yeah, I love everything else. Love your art and character designs. Perfects tools to make some great submissions. Keep up the good work! :)

meichel responds:

Thank you, I really appreciate the feedback! :) Will consider BGM in the future but iunno how I wanna go about it just yet, and I def wanna put more time into the actual animation of future works. ThAnk you again, dog bless

[Fight Away]

For a school project this was pretty good. The art was the best part about it imo. You got fantastic drawing skills. Also the animation was pretty smooth for the most part. Hope you got an A with this lol. Though if I was you, I would've put in some sound effects or music. Would've made the submission a little bit more engaging. But it's great for what it is. Keep up the good work!

EddyPaintings responds:

Thanks man, I was trying with audio and music recently, however I couldn't find anything good, nor do I have the knowledge at sound engineering. Luckily I am not getting grades on audio, thanks for your kind comments and advice man!

[Flash Sticks]

Feels like something off Stickpage; a very nostalgic feel. That was pretty hilarious lol. It's nothing amazing, but it made me smile. Keep up the good work! :)

Btw, what did the original submission look like? You got me curious.

Pixelcraftian responds:

It's most likely the same, just some animations tweaks, a MP4 version, and a better replay/links screen as well as a bonus scene later and you got yourself the unblammed version. Just trying to make people happy :] Glad you enjoyed :D

[Widdle Baby]

The best animation I've seen in years. Keep up the amazing work dude! :D

FlippinDollar responds:

aw shucks what can i say

["What You'll Lose"]

My only criticism is that the submission could've went a bit slower, just to really let the drama impact the audience. But yeah, I love what you have here. Wasn't even in a linear perspective, but with two scenarios playing back to back. And you could tell quick what happened despite the animation going too fast. Keep up the good work!

ChicPigeon responds:

thank you <3, yeah most people have been telling me it goes by too fast so I'm working on a slower version rn. Thanks for the critique :)

[The Worm God]

The backgrounds and the color schemes were giving me Dragonball vibes, also with the worm god looking like Shenron. And the main guy was giving me Phineas & Ferb vibes. Never thought the looks of both franchises would collide lol. But yeah, that was kind of funny. Keep up the good work! :)

egglebreg responds:

thanks!

[The FNaF Story [S1EP2: Awakening]]

This is honestly bland at best, just like how most gmod submissions are. It's unfortunate because I've seen plenty of good gmod stuff in the past, and they actually got some great animation going on. This just felt like a slideshow of pictures and nothing more. I probably wouldn't be so harsh if literally anything happened in this submission. But nope, nothing happened at all. I get you want to make these shorter, but they need to have some sort of plot thread to them. Just have something to engage the audience with. Don't think I'm hating on you, it's just some constructive criticism. If I didn't tell you this, somebody will. All I can say now is improve and good luck!

TheFantasticAero responds:

Making animations in GMod is hard, and I do have a good plot for this series, it's just hard to achieve it because of limitations.

[Roadtrip]

What was the original song? (Decent animation btw lol)

Carsaurus responds:

The original song was "freaking Out the Neighborhood" by Mac DeMarco, and personally I think it better suits the animation but whatever. If you wanna see the original video its up on my YT channel