ShaeGuy's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[wolf and hunter]

This was pretty enjoyable! The only real problem I have with this is that the animation is on loop. I strongly recommend Swivel so it will not loop around. It is a free newgrounds program, so it should be no problem to get. Besides that, everything about this submission is cute and enjoyable. The animation is slow, but very smooth. The art and line work looks really great in my opinion. And the overall story is just hilarious! Just work on getting the newgrounds video player, and you will be all set! I look forward to seeing more content from you. Keep up the amazing work! :)

[Markiplier Animated - Bendy and the ink machine chapter 2]

While it's really nothing special, it is pretty entertaining at least. While I'm not much of a fan for the art and line work, the animation itself makes up for it. Obviously, the animation here is the main focus and not the art itself. Not to mention some of the scenes you chose to animate (which are some great choices by the way lol). It's a cute, charming little piece of work that has talent and effort put into, and I really appreciate that!

By the way, about the "please be gentle..." comment, everyone has the right to judge submissions like yours as they please. There are going to be some folks that will be rather harsh towards you and your animations, and you need to learn to embrace what you get. Not to mention, it doesn't help that you sort of jinxed yourself by saying that. Just be careful on what you say next time.

With all of this said, I do wish you the best of luck on your animations. See you later.

Jmainia responds:

Thanks for the feedback! I am trying to improve my artwork bit by bit!

[The Way of the Samurai]

I really do like the animation here! Not to mention the art and line work on the samurai and his weapon. You obviously have some really good talent here. However, something this short and non-engaging should've been on your dumping grounds instead of being submitted under judgement. Also, I strongly recommend Swivel so the animation is not on loop. It's a free newgrounds program, so it should be no problem to get. Again, you got plenty of potential here. It just needs to be explored more. So with that said, I hope you get better in the future. Good luck!

RMAnimations responds:

Thanks that means a lot! I did use swivel, and the character design of this guy was so complex that it took like 2 weeks to make this. Next time i should focus on length and not have the character so detailed.

[Clash of Clans parody]

While the animation can be a little bit choppy at certain points, I do appreciate everything else. I'm sure some folks would not like slow paced animations like this one, but I do. Nothing like a chuckle to get your morning started! The color scheme is pretty good to look at, and so is the art and line work here. Again, you just need to bring up the frame rate a bit so that the characters can move a lot smoother than in the submission here. I wish you the best of luck. Keep up the good work!

MartysAnimatio responds:

Thank you :-) I appreciate your comment .
MartyS

[The Seeker]

I really do have a soft spot for claymations, especially ones that are done right like this for example! For starters, I really do love the overall setup for the scenery. It looks so surreal and everything, which I know that was the point lol. Love the alien-like world here! The character in this was also pretty interesting. Love the model because of how weird it looks. Though to be fair, I think the frames in certain parts could've been improved just a little bit more. Like whenever he was picking up the worm thing to eat it. But that is just a nitpick. Overall, this is pretty amazing! Forgot to mention the music makes the whole thing atmospheric. And I really do appreciate it! This was a piece of art, and I hope you keep up the good work! Have fun! :)

[The New Colossus Disenchanted]

Short, but very effective! The overall quality is really impressive. For starters, the art style is really great in my opinion. It stands out pretty well as much as the color scheme does (which is also good btw). The animation is also pretty good too. And the overall message was pretty powerful for a video that is less than a minute long. Not to mention the music was a perfect choice for an illustration like this. I really do like this submission overall, and I hope you keep up the good work. Good luck! :)

[Rogue orc. First reward]

Got a lot of "World of Warcraft" feels from this lol. Especially love the music and sound effects that came from WoW. Besides that, the quality for this submission was pretty good. While I'm not usually a fan of tween animation, I really had no problems with it here. The overall art style is pretty simple at best in my opinion, but that is what I love about work like this. Sometimes you have to appreciate the little things. Not to mention the plot for this video was hilarious, especially at the ending when he got the gloves. The color scheme was also pretty good. It somehow makes the scenery atmospheric or something lol. This submission overall was really enjoyable to me, and I hope you keep up the hard work! Good luck! :)

Qstick responds:

Thank you for such a great review. It gives me a strong desire to continue the story C:

[Trouble in the Tardis]

I really do like the art style here. Really does stand out in my opinion. Not to mention it's pretty funny, especially right at the ending lol. Keep up the good work! lol